At the risk of speaking for other adoptees,
here’s how I would answer the question: What do angry transracial adoptees want?
We want to feel like we belong, unconditionally.
We want to feel welcome wherever we go.
We want to not be stared at when we go out with our families.
We don’t want to be asked, Is that your real mother/sister/brother/father?
We don’t want to be asked, Would you rather have been left in the orphanage/group home/foster home/street to die?
We want people to keep their hands off our hair.
We want people to stop being curious about our skin, our eyes, our hair, our bodies.
We want to feel normal.
We want to be treated as mature adults and not little children.
We want our sealed records to be unsealed already.
We want our original birth certificates.
We want our foster care files, and our orphanage records.
We want to be able to know for certain if the person we are about to have sex with is biologically related to us.
We want to know where our biological siblings are.
We want to be able to contact our first families—our foster families who took care of us, our biological families whose genetic and cultural heritage we share, our blood brothers and sisters left behind in orphanages and group homes.
We want ALL our questions answered.
We don’t want to be paid for, to be sold, or treated like commodities.
We don’t want to be told we are “lucky.”
We don’t want to be abused.
We don’t want to be exploited.
We don’t want to be studied, researched, and psychoanalyzed, especially when research studies merely justify the pain we have been forced to endure.
We don’t want non-adopted people to build careers off our pain and our struggles.
We don’t want to be the “diversity experience” for our school, our house of worship, our neighbors, or our families.
We don’t want to be told how to feel—don’t feel so angry, don’t feel so sad. Don’t feel bitter. Feel happy, feel grateful, feel lucky.
We want information about diseases we may be carrying, and medical conditions we may be susceptible to.
We want to not have to leave page after page blank when we go to the doctor and give our medical history.
We want to be treated the same as the children born into our adoptive families.
We want our legal inheritance rights to never be contested at the reading of the wills.
We want to be treated without teasing about our origins, as if we aren’t really part of the family.
We don’t want to be told that we aren’t really African American or Asian American, that we’re not real Indians or Latinos, as if we are somehow a fake version of our ethnicity of origin.
We want to be able to go to the store, the movies, the park, or the mall and not be followed around, stared at and singled out.
We want to not be called names, teased, or bullied because we are different.
We want to fit in, and to be able to blend into our environment.
We want to be around people who look like us.
We want to be around other families that resemble ours.
We want to know LOTS of other adopted people.
We don’t want to forever be the oddball, the token, the weirdo, the one who was obviously adopted.
We want to control who knows our adoption status and who gets to hear our adoption story.
We want to be treated with respect.
We want to be loved.
We want to be listened to.
We don’t want to be patronized.
We don’t want to be your token.
We don’t want to be your Asian / Black /Latino /Native /Pacific Islander /African friend.
We don’t want to have our so-called issues ridiculed.
We don’t want to be pathologized.
We want to see ourselves and our families reflected realistically on TV, at the movies, in magazines, and in advertisements.
We want to be part of the majority.
We want the privileges that others get just by being born into their families.
We want to NOT have to decide whether or not to search.
We want information about our origins collected and safeguarded for us for when we are ready to receive it.
We want the power of self-determination.
We want first class–not second class– citizenship. No questions asked.
We want to know how to act Colombian or Black or Native or Korean or Indian or Guatemalan or Ethiopian or Chinese so that when we meet others who look like us, we can fit in and feel comfortable, instead of anxious, unsure of ourselves, incompetent and scared.
We want our families to stand with us against racism, against genocide, and against the destruction of our birth families and communities.
We want families who believe us when we say something racist just happened.
We want our families to speak out against prejudice and oppression.
We want our classmates and teachers to stop being ignorant and small-minded about racial differences.
We want adults to stop romanticizing our cultures.
We want you to stop fetishizing our bodies: our hair, our skin colors, our eyes, our genitals, and other so-called racial differences.
We want you to stop appropriating our culture.
We want families to stop bragging about how they got us.
We want families to stop parading us in front of the company or neighbors.
We want families to stop showing us off in front of the congregation.
We want families to teach us how to be secure in our skin and comfortable with who we are.
We want families to feel as uncomfortable as we often do. Why should we bear the brunt of the racial differences in the family all by ourselves?
We want to have allies by our side, to trust that somebody’s got our back.
We want to learn about our countries and communities of origin. But we don’t want to be forced to go to “culture camp.”
We don’t want to be forced to follow your religion.
We want to be able to ask questions without worrying about hurting anyone’s feelings or risking our place in the family.
We want to be able to talk about our birth families without our adoptive relatives becoming uncomfortable or angry.
We want to be able to talk about our adoptive families without our birth relatives becoming sad.
We want to be able to express how we really feel without you getting mad or sad.
We want to be able to get information when we want it.
We want to be able to not be subjected to insensitive remarks or intrusive questions from random strangers, neighbors, and even friends.
We want the same gifts that the kids born into the family get from extended family members.
We don’t want to have to wonder all the time if this is an adoption-related issue.
We don’t want to have to wonder all the time if something happened because of our race.
We don’t want to be treated like your pet, your project, or the object of your missionary zeal.
We want to be ourselves.
We don’t want to be a poster child for someone else’s cause.
We want to be able to choose.
We want to be able to love more than one set of parents and one set of siblings.
We want to be able to live without waiting for some surprise to pop up unexpectedly: some long lost relative or birth parent, some former caregiver surprising us out of nowhere.
We want the security of knowing that we will never be abandoned again.
We want to be told the truth, and not some feel-good fantasy of “how much we were loved so that is why we were given away.”
We want to trust that our place in our family is forever secure.
We want to believe that we are as capable and lovable as the next person.
We want security.
We want free and fluid identities.
We want inner peace.
We want freedom from racism, sexism, homophobia, classism, and other forms of oppression.
We want social justice.
When we take a stance for freedom and social justice, we want allies standing with us.
We don’t want to carry the burden of difference alone.
We don’t want to fight our battles alone.
We don’t want to fight for adoption reform by ourselves.
We don’t want to fight racism by ourselves.
We want equality NOW.
We want freedom.
We want justice.
We want to be with each other, with fellow adoptees.
We want to be in charge of our lives.
We want our humanity.
We want community.
We want our first families back.
We want our given names.
We want to speak our native languages.
We want our original citizenship reinstated, and dual citizenship if we were forced to leave our motherland.
We want to feel that we count.
We want to feel wanted for who we really are, not who you want us to be.
We want to feel that we matter.
We want to feel real.
We want to be left alone.
We don’t want to feel like the outsider.
We want to blend in.
We want a space to breathe in and breathe out without someone questioning us or invalidating our experience.
We want adoption to be about us and what we need, and not about parents–birth parents or adoptive parents.
We want adoptee empowerment.
We want to be able to take a break from being adopted. Frankly, it’s exhausting.
Finally, we want transracial adoption not to hurt so damn much.

I hear every one of these, and want them all for you, for my kids, and for every adopted person. Where the system has made or is making this impossible, I’ll work to change it.
And to the best of my ability, I will have your back.
Sad thing is? non-adopted folk get to take all this and more for granted.
Thanks for your witness, John, and for speaking the truths in my heart.
You know, I just had a few exchanges at work where co-workers asked where I was from and what about my parents.
I want to be able to say “I’m Chinese and my parents are from Taiwan” without feeling like I’m lying.
Or that I need to prove I’m Chinese by speaking the language or knowing about the food or understanding the culture.
I am so tempted to try and speak just a little bit in Chinese, but then am scared shitless because they’ll judge me for Not Being Able To Speak The Language despite being ethnically Chinese.
“We don’t want to be asked, Would you rather have been left in the orphanage/group home/foster home/street to die?”
I’m so tired of that question.
Amazing.
Powerful!
I want those things for you…all of them.
Thank you for this info. It helps me a great deal to hear this type of ino from an adoptee rather than from someone who assumes they know how adoptees feel.
Truly that is not too much to ask for.
May I repost this on my FB page ‘you know you’re an adoptee when…’ ? excellent post and I think it would resonate with the readers there.
This is awesome, thank you.
I found myself drawn to this statement, and keep thinking about it: “We want to be treated the same as the children born into our adoptive families.”
I am conflicted by this…Im not sure why. Maybe for me, if I was treated the same, it would invalidate who I was, invalidate my origins? This has given me food for thought.
Your recent posts have been especially profound and incredibly powerful for me. Thank you for your voice, John. Thank you.
Thank you for this….
It is a great risk to try to speak for other adoptees.
I personally do not want to be part of a majority not do I want to know lots of adoptees.I would prefer to see adoption die out; it is unethical, immoral an inhumane.
Right on, John. And I want to add, “We want you to stop viewing our community as a niche market in which you can hawk your goods and services for a quick buck, especially if you clearly have no intention of really serving or knowing us.” (Now, if only I had the courage to say that to a particular someone’s face !!)
I’m working hard to be an ally. This helps. Thank you so much for sharing.
Thanks. THis is a wonderful and thoguht provoking peice. I will share it with other adoptive parents.
As the father of an Ethiopian, i try my best to consider these questions. But is everything here attainable?
What does success look like?
Is every transracial adoptee angry?
Man, this sums it all up so potently, John. I wish EVERY adoptive parent, prospective adoptive parent, social worker, anyone connected to adoption in any way would read this! Definitely linking to this…And actually, wish it was a poster so I could hang it on my wall!
Thank you.
John,
Allow me to offer another option…..as an adoptee and the proud father of my own adopted daughter.
I “want” alot of things for my daughter of Asia desecent.
Until I read your want and don’t want list the following never really got much attention, I am too busy relearning my life through the eyes, hopes and dreams of my new daughter.
I don’t believe my daughters parents gave her up out of “love” as you say but because they had no other option…..I cannot imagine their grief or the long years of wondering what happened to their daughter. It hurts my heart to think about because I have kids and cannot fathom the courage and heart break it took to place my daughter on that police station door step.
I never really cared that people knew that I was adopted.
I did consider myself lucky to have caring, loving and special parents.
I did consider myself lucky too get adopted but didn’t know it until I was almost 18 years old. I know that will be alittle different with my daughter.
I wasn’t paraded around and my daughter isn’t. People noticed a difference but no more than people looking at me and wondering how I got such a beautiful wife. I don’t care if they look….maybe it will inspire them too offer a child a life. If your church wants to make an issue out of it…..go to a different church.
I know there is a difference in my skin color and my daughter’s but I didn’t really noticed until I read your article. I have spend 30 years in the military and I notice only one color…..red. All my few servicemen bleed as well as all my countries enemies…..the other colors don’t matter. And I have seen way too much of it.
I didn’t want to meet my bio-parents but if my daughter wants to meet hers I will go to the ends of the earth to find them for her. It will be her decision.
I don’t hear racial comments, I don’t listen for them and people say really dumb things.. I’m not stupid I know they are out there….not unlike they are for kids who are not adopted. We deal with it…..that is the reality of life.
As I read your article it started to sound alot like I want……I don’t want. My daughter will not have an easy life and it will be filled with alot of difficult and heart-breaking decisions and experiences….not unlike my life or my two biological daughters….that is why we are a family…we stick together.
John,
I know I am going to take alot heat for this but it sounds to me like you are whining. If you are an adoptee and your family reads this I cannot imagine how they feel. I did not adopt for credit with GOD and there was not a calling, booming voice or spritual experience that compelled me to do it. I did it because it was the right thing to do….we all must give back and no one makes in this world without some help from others. I will give you some advice…..move on, be grateful you are alive and know that GOD and your family loves you…..regardless of what your records say, or where your birth certificate is from. I feel like I am the lucky one….I got a beauitiful daughter, a great family and a life. Your list is what every single human being in the world wants and is trying too get. It is alot more difficult for some to get there but they don’t give up. I have traveled the world, I have seen it at it best and at its worse. The one place that stood out to me was Nepal. You could probably buy it with a year’s salary. These people lived in the most austure conditions, picked through garbage for dinner, and most of the buildings were falling apart……but they had the most incredible spirit of all the people I have ever met in the world. They knew they had it bad and future didn’t offer much relief but they were positive. They all dressed in bright colors and tried to make what little clothes they had look good. They are a proud people and they do something you don’t see much in the US…..they looked out for each other. It made me feel so grateful for what I had, and that the most important thing was to never give up, find the positive in everything and move on. I get up each morning and thank God for my life , my family and for my friends. I have only one regret when it comes too adoption….that I could not offer all those kids a life….I to think it is a real crime of society that we as a people have to have adoption. I could not save them all but I did save one and if everyone saved just one….adoption would be a thing of the past. Too dwell on the past is to relive it.
“What does success look like?”
I would say it depends on one’s factors of success. But I would also say that lack of support/resources to a family who feels they must “owe” their child to a prospective adoptive family is not success.
If there is a success, it should be the biological family’s (provided they aren’t abusive, of course).
“Is every transracial adoptee angry?”
Some are angry about their adoptions, and yet content with their adoptive families.
I want to add my voice to the chorus of support. Wonderful post. And, I would add to the list: “We want to see ourselves in family portraits with people who look like us” and “We want the people who took us out of our countries in the first place, to help pay for us to go back”
I hear what you are trying to say. But no one has all of this. That would truly be utopia, wouldn’t it?
In response to Tara’s post. How many of these kids do think want to go back and live a life of poverty and forced labor. Sharing a room with 26 other kids,with no possible future in their country unless you think they would like earning pennies a day. Living in conditions that are so bad we cannot even imagine. If my daughter wants to go back I will not only pay for it but I would love to go with her. She is old enough to notice the differences and has yet to mention her former life. If we bring it up she ignores us or leaves the room. Tara, I truly believe her when she says that she is happy and is proud to be an American citizen. As for the pictures……has saving a life come down to looking good in a photo or looking like everyone else in it. I think alot of people lost site of the big picture. Just to add my daughter is proud of her looks and is the biggest camera hound in the world….especially if she can ham it up with her non-asian looking sisters. There is no such thing a free ride or the perfect world. Just watch the news.
“Tara, I truly believe her when she says that she is happy and is proud to be an American citizen”
I’m proud to be a Canadian citizen.
I’m not proud of the system which led circumstances in such a way that I needed to become one – because the power imbalance is what led me to become an *adopted* Canadian citizen.
Also, I find that when I say “I am Canadian-Chinese”, people often tell me “No, you weren’t raised by Chinese people. You are Canadian.”
One nationality is expected to override the other.
“I will give you some advice…..move on, be grateful you are alive and know that GOD and your family loves you…..regardless of what your records say, or where your birth certificate is from.”
Sure, we can be grateful for what we have. Grateful, like any other non-adopted child, for our families – for our education, for food, for clothing, for shelter, for support.
On the other hand, “grateful” takes up a loaded term in adoption.
We shouldn’t need to feel grateful that we got (through adoption) what every single child deserves.
As another adoptee, I don’t mind it when people tell me (in a non-adoption scenario) to be grateful for what I have.
I wouldn’t mind it in an adoption-related scenario if they would actually say it with some real compassion – rather than as a “would you have preferred to grow up in an orphanage” passive silencing tactic.
It is true, it is tired, and it is ridiculous. No one would have preferred to grow up an in orphanage, an institution, or on the streets, so the question is moot.
The question isn’t moot it is reality. The world is not a perfect place and it sliding further away from being civilized. As for people saying be grateful with compassion….I think it is s situation that they haven’t been down your road of life so they don’t know any better. I have moved on with my life because it does no good to dwell on the past which I cannot change. I would ask you to look at the history of mankind and find one time the entire world agreed on human rights and wasn’t at war to achieve it. No one is proud of the current system that has led us to adoption but for now it is all we have to work with. I am not happy that adoption is part of my past. That my parents choose to abandon me than to try to raise me….but I can tell you after reseaching and finding out where they ended up in life, that I was “”grateful” that they choose to do it. Being an American is more of a feeling than a nationality….we are the melting pot of the world and made it work…..at times.
Being ANGRY is a waste of time. Living life with chip on your shoulder achieves nothing. Adoption is saving lives one child at a time.
Robert – why are you here on this blog if you have moved on? To chastise a successful, highly educated, sensitive and compassionate adoptee and adoptive parent who gives considerable amounts of his own personal time trying to make life better for all adoptees?
If adoptees do not speak to the challenges then who will? Every single adoptee has a unique experience, personality and parents but there will be similar experiences that could be made better by aware adoptive parents. Is it wrong to educate and be educated?
I have followed John’s blog for years but have never spoken until now.
“The question isn’t moot it is reality.”
The question in itself: Would you have preferred to grow up in an orphanage?
The answer you clearly expect from adoptees: No, I would not have.
So what is the point in asking? We already know what answer you want, and we already know what to say and that you know we know what we feel we should be answering.
“I have moved on with my life because it does no good to dwell on the past which I cannot change.”
You know, I could apply things to an awful lot of things in my life that have nothing to do with adoption, but I also wouldn’t hear people saying “Be grateful you have a loving family and think of all the things you’ve been given!” to my face.
You say “Think of the poor children!” as long as they are in orphanages. Then, you see other adult adoptees “whining” online and you tell them “be grateful you’re even alive and you have a loving family.”
So they’re deserving of love & pity while they’re in the orphanage, and as soon as they’ve been adopted, they need to feel grateful for having said loving family? Really?
“Being ANGRY is a waste of time.”
I’ll be sure to tell that to everyone in my life next time they get angry about something non-adoption related. I mean, if they’d only look at what they have, right? Loving families, a good education, and good homes. I mean, that just trumps all emotions and feelings they should be having.
I’m sure my “positive” outlook will bring about a revelation and immediately cease all loss and burdens that they live with.
“You know, I could apply things”
That should say “I could apply -that”
Sorry for the typos, I’ve been running low on sleep these days…
I would like to add to the list:
- We would like to not be told who to love, how much, to what quality and when.
- We would like not to be kicked out of our adoptive heritages. We inherited them fairly.
- We are not only adoptees of our blood, but also where we grew up.
I encountered a lot of the first two.
And for the adoptive parents that told us not to be angry and to be grateful: Wow, I didn’t know you actually existed. I’d love to spend a lot of time dissecting your beliefs and find out how you came to think this way.
Thank you for writing this. I agree about all of it but I especially would want dual citizenship for my child. Why not? Also, I wish all birth parents got to choose the adoptive parents the way it is often in American Domestic adoption.
John,
You rock.
To add my 2 cents to the comments, when someone says “move on,” or suggests that one can avoid marginalizing experiences, they’ve failed to understand the perspective of the person who is speaking.
Part of compassion for others is acknowledging that we all may have an experience with the same entity, adoption, a church, a place of business, so on and so forth, and all of our experiences might be different but none more or less valid than the other. Convincing another person not to share their perspective or their grief, my, what does that solve?
How does one avoid racism? How does one avoid adoptism? How does one “move on” from what others continually subject them to? To “avoid” these things would mean to turn off the TV, never read another book or watch a movie, leave the house or talk to another person.
When we make it the responsibility of a marginalized person not to feel impacted by the ignorance of others, we are making excuses for the ignorance. Why make excuses for ignorance when we could encourage the person who is spreading the information and education to change it?
Asking an adoptee to be “grateful” is just another adoption stereotype. When children receive basic human rights, such as love, a home, food, and clothes, it is “justice” not “luck.” I would never ask my son to be grateful to me for doing my job as a parent.
Dear John,
I happened to stumble on your blog through an internet search, and I couldn’t be more grateful and so deeply moved.
I’m a non-adopted sibling of mixed race with two beautiful brothers, one a transnational/transracial adoptee and the other who is an all-white half-brother. Race and racism has been something that has run light and heavy in our blended family. Our inability to discuss it as a family has been something that has pained both me and my adoptee brother.
You’ve raised so many questions for me, especially for how I can be a better sibling and ally to my brother. I can’t picture my life without him—I don’t know who I would have become—I wouldn’t be me. Still, I recognize my own actions in some of your statements, and it makes me feel a deep remorse and humbles me, especially since I also have the intention to adopt when I get older. I will have a lot to reflect upon as well as a lot to learn.
Thank you for speaking out. Thank you so much for treading into this hard place with compassionate courage. Thank you.
Hi John! I haven’t been very present in the online adoption scene, recently. This is a great post, though!
Hey I’m late to the party, but I wanted to drop you a note to say that THIS AP enjoyed reading your blog. I’m familiar with you some, through Kevin Hoffman. Kevin’s work has brought me far as an adoptive parent.. I look forward to you stretching this “pollyanna parent” further in terms of how I think about TRA.
im 11 and im being adopted
really? exciting!!